3. No. If Murray told Paden on May 26th that the house had a concrete foundation it would not …show more content…
Gorsuch definitely committed fraud. He knew from the beginning that the ticket and postcards had a significant monetary value. In addition, it doesn’t make any since for Gorsuch to tell Westby that the ticket and postcards were “worth nothing” then give Westby $1,000 for both the ticket and the postcard album. If they are truly been worthless then he wouldn’t have gave Westby $1,000 for them. In addition, Gorsuch was a major buyer in antiques and collectibles in the Puget Sound area and he would have had an understanding of the value of the ticket and postcards. Gorsuch knew that the items were worth a lot of money and he choose not to tell Westby their actual value. Moreover, Gorsuch knew that he was telling Westby false statements about the value of the ticket and postcards. He knew that it was a lie when he told Westby that the ticket and post cards were “worth nothing”. Gorsuch committed fraud. I would rule in favor of Westby in this