David Reimer Case Summary

Improved Essays
In arguably one of the most notable case studies in psychology history, the case of David Reimer tried to answer questions on gender identity and overrule nurture over nature in development of sex differences. However, this case highlighted the blunders of the science and medical community with the individual living a majority of his life in psychology stress. Once he found out what occurred to him when he was younger, as he put it, he realized he wasn’t crazy for how he was feeling. It could be said that these were one of the cases that set up the theories and hypothesis we now have on gender identity and the dimorphic differences we witness in the sexes. Our history is abundant with unethical studies that have happened, such as the Stanford …show more content…
Indeed, this was a major theory endorsed by John Money. With the lack of rsearch on the topic, this case study was used as a trial for the theory, with David being born a male, but external male genitial being removed and an attempt to being raised as a female, in terms acting in a more female manner and during adolescent taking female hormones to endues the conversion. Howeverr, we now know this wasn’t the proper way to go about the issue of an invidual sans a penis. The answer of simply converting him to a female was a controversial one as the inidvudla displayed many problems during his transition, until he converted back to being a male. The issue stems from the biological changes that occurred even in the womb that differs from that of a biological female. The organization-activation theory is important to note because prenatally, testerone acts directly on cells to induce male development, such as the sex determing region on the Y chromosome which contain the testis determing factor. David was biologically a male and developed testes and had this added testerone even before he was born. A female on the other hand, just lacks testerone and automatically develops female reproductive organs. With the testerone in utero, the Wolffian ducts normally

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Tiwi People Case Study

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As a matter of fact, before birth a female baby is already…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Capistrano Unified School District took the parents of Jeremy Wartenberg, Wayne and Charlene Wartenberg to court in their refusal to pay for Jeremy’s private school tuition, fees spent at the private school, and attorney fees. The school district expresses that Jeremy’s behavior comes from his own willfulness to misbehave not his disability. The school psychologist, although acknowledging that Jeremy had a learning disability of attention deficit disorder (ADD), which allowed for an IEP and services, felt that it was not sever enough to be a contributing factor to his behavior. He felt that Jeremy’s primary behavior was largely related to his failure to work, cooperate, and school truancies rather than his primarily disability of ADD. He acknowledged that Jeremy’s behavior could be a contributing factor of his Conduct Disorder, which is not covered under a learning…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the individuals, whom I knew pretty well because we both shadowed at the same obstetric practice, took her life after being subjected to constant torment and finally, after losing her shadowing opportunity when one of the female patients discover that she was born a male and identified (therefore appeared) to be a female. The patient felt lied to and or violated and thus insisted on the girl’s expulsion. After her dismissal, she began to feel less and less sure of herself, often feeling as if she had no idea of her true identity. Identity cresses such as these pressure students so much that they feel no way out, but the future us certainly changing with the help of writers such as Anderson-Minshall, Gutierrez- Mock, and…

    • 1033 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evidently, this also shows that the human brain has the ability to adjust itself through different environmental interactions. Ultimately, Wade’s claim becomes clear as she obliterates these biological bases (genes, hormones, and brain) as sex definers. The minor biological differences that exist are not enough to divide gender into simply male or female, gender goes far beyond these two categories. Rather, she proves that societal influences on our biology are in fact what shape us, showing that male/females are more similar than believed to be. Overall, every individual manifests themselves through the different life experiences that have helped mold them into the human being they…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Gender remains a contentious and among the most explored concept in many academic fields, including psychology. Some theorists and researchers base their perspectives on neurochemical, biological and evolutionary factors while others base their gender arguments on culture and socialization. While the division on what entails gender continues, there have been different attempts to eliminate the issue of gender roles in society. In An Unconventional Family, Sandra Lipsitz Bem provides a memoir describing their attempt with her husband to defy family traditions. The book provides an account of an unconventional couple that was determined to go against pre-determined gender roles in society.…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beyond Genetics (Karen Horney’s Views on the Psychological Differences Between Men and Women) Imagine you’re in the delivery room, prepared to give birth for the first time. You’re expecting fraternal twins; Hazel and Harvey. From the time that they are born into this world and each year that they age, you have to learn and adjust to each of their needs. When they are an infant, to toddler, teenager and then adult raising both your twins is a challenge due to their different genders. It’s not a surprise that women and men look differently physically, but emotionally and mentally women and men differ as well.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender Issues In Intersex

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Intersex is a group of conditions where there is a discrepancy between the external genitals and the internal genitals (the testes and ovaries)” (Kaneshiro, 2) Intersexuallity is a essence of being born with a mixture of both male and female biological characteristics, which are caused by an error in the sex chromosomes. Since both sides are present, it is very difficult for physicians to deal with issues involving the assignment of a specific sex or any consultations revolving around the issue. Intersexuality has been a major topic in medicine through history as has been subjected to a lot of controversy and different procedures. Even in the present day and age there are a lot of differences between how its viewed in distinct cultures and…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This peer review article was about the deconstructing of GID (Gender Identity Disorder), due to gender Identity being an evolving disorder that is controversial. The main reason a person suffer from gender Identity is because their gender does not fit their external makeup. In Saralyns’ article she exposes the concealed inner theory and the inconsistency and undermine in its apparent meaning or unanimity. The author also state that “These diagnosis leads to stigmatisms and results in stress, this is why some people reject the diagnosis of GID” (Russell, 2013). Transsexual theories have been around since 1966, however none of them seem seems fit or respect the individual’s identity diagnosis.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ambiguous Genitalia Essay

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Two of the tests the child will undergo once the child is born are to determine the sex and also to rule out that the child does not have congenital adrenal hyperplasia, which is a rare genetic disorder and classified as a medical emergency (15 Notable Ambiguous Genitalia Statistics, 2014). Once that test has been established and the child has been identified as male or female, the child will go into surgery to try and preserve normal sexual functioning and also to create more natural looking genitals. Results of the surgery are often satisfying, but repeated surgeries may be needed later. Studies show that about half the children born with this disorder will wind up with sexually sensitive tissue that may wither or die (15 Notable Ambiguous Genitalia Statistics, 2014). With this being said, as the child continues to grow to an adulthood he might have psychological problems and his chances to encounter bullying are now doubled.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This could be the reason why the author states, “but only our beliefs about gender, not science can define our sex” (Fausto-Sterling, 5). Anne Fausto-Sterling additionally states, “our beliefs about gender affect what kinds of knowledge scientists produce about sex in the first place” (Fausto-Sterling, 5). This quote additionally proves the author's reason to why she believes that gender norms are socially and not scientifically like some individuals want to propose. Furthermore, the author refers to the “second-wave feminists of 1970s” and states that this is an idea that states, “that sex is distinct from gender that social institutions, themselves designed to perpetuate gender inequality, produce most of the differences between men and women” (Fausto-Sterling, 6). Basically, what this idea presents is socialization as the main factor which creates the concept of gender, rather than a physiological perspective.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It has been numerously mentioned what social masculinity and femininity stands for. For example, “Diamond argues that these children should be assigned to the male sex since the presence of the Y is sufficient grounds for the presumption of social masculinity” (748). She also mentions that it is not “feminine” (“Interview: John Colapinto”) of “Brenda” (744) to play with guns, trucks or even to stand and urinate, because as a society we have come up with the generalization that one is a male if XY chromosomes are present in an individual’s gene, and one is a female if XX chromosomes are present. Therefore, Butler apprises us by using David Reimer’s case to define that “what is feminine and what is masculine can be altered, that these cultural terms have no fixed meaning or internal destiny, and that they are more malleable than previously thought” (746). Stating that biology does not set the limit for one’s destiny, because there are alternative routes that one might take, which could be completely different than what their biology had put forth for them.…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, our sex is not always so set in stone. During conception embryo’s start their development with out any sexual organs and two gonads. Eventually, through development the gonads become ovaries or testes. Although, the reason is unclear, development is disrupted while in the womb causing genitalia and/or other factors to not form normally. Ambiguous, or some know it as “intersex”, babies do not have a definitive line to establish them as boy or girl.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In regards to gender, the “nature versus nurture” debate refers the opposition between a biologically-based conception and one grounded in social psychology. On the “nature” side, gender is a matter of a person 's physiological makeup. There are varying accounts of what body parts specifically are indicative of gender, with gonads, chromosomes, and reproductive organs being among the contenders for criterion of gender. Regardless, on this view gender and sex are correlated, and “male” and “female” are the only existing categories. Those individuals born with the appropriate “male” physiology are men, and those with the corresponding correct “female” anatomy are women.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Woolf entails that it is inevitable for a man to obtain feminine qualities and vice versa. This is blurring the lines between genders as it proves that there are no manifest distinction of gender. Therefore, psychological behaviors are a fundamental evidence to obscure the separation between…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I was surprised to learn that most people who do not identify with their biological gender, do not feel they are that gender. If someone is born with female reproductive organs and hormones, but don’t feel they fit the role of a female, they will live their lives believing they are male. This was a strange concept for me before this course. I was naive to think that if one is born a female, they play the part of a female and if one is born a male, they play the part of a male. After reading the chapters of the textbook, and reviewing the PowerPoint provided on this topic, I strongly believe I have applied what I have learned from this topic in my everyday life.…

    • 1301 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays