Zero Tolerance Policing Case Study

Superior Essays
The impacts from the preventative strategy gained community support for its successful outcome in hot spot experiments in 55 areas in Minneapolis. Be that as it may, it still receives a fair share of criticism by scholars, believing the implementation will increase the fear of crime and reduce collective efficacy. On the other hand, the relationship between the police and community is threatened by the lack of discretion provided by zero tolerance policing and jeopardizes the legitimacy. The legitimacy of Hot spot policing, however, is the opposite from Zero tolerance because of its support of the community, raising the popularity of the preventative strategy.

Zero tolerance policing takes tough on crime approach as police officers enforce every detail of the law when broken (Grabosky 1999). The concept of the preventive strategy is harsh towards those breaking the
…show more content…
The lack of discretion had increased civil case complaints against police officers in New York City by over 75% from their misconduct and abuse (Greene 1999). In fact, the very idea of zero tolerance itself conflicts with community policing, which concentrates on the legitimacy and discretion of police conduct (Putt 2010 & Grabosky 1999).

Theoretical stances explain the long-term consequences for those arrested for minor offenses by officers following the broken window theory (Grabosky 1999). These effects are members seeking employment after the time of their arrest, having difficulty finding a job because of the restrictions of an arrest record (Grabosky 1999). There is also a chance that already over-represented groups, like Indigenous Australians, are going to be more over-represented from the implementation of Zero tolerance, possibly leading to difficulty in political ramifications (Grabosky

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    KCPD Summary

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In an effort to reduce an extremely high violent rate of crime in the city of Kansas City, Missouri, the Bureau of Justice Assistance’s Smart Policing Initiative (SPI) provided a grant to the Kansas City Police Department (KCPD) in 2011 with the expectations that the KCPD would implement innovative methods for reducing crime in this article titled Kansas City, Missouri Smart Policing Initiative From Foot Patrol to Focused Deterrence, Novak, Fox, Carr, McHale, and White (2015) provide a review of the strategies that the KCPD implemented with the funding that was provided over a four year period. We will examine the two deterrent strategies implemented in this experiment which include foot patrol by the police officers targeted in the areas that…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    At the conclusion of the Kansas City Preventative Patrol Experiment of 1974, little worth was placed on the proficiency of defensive routine patrols to discourage crime. Researchers and criminologists exposed inadequacies in methodology, specifically a bias in the statistics towards a worthless hypothesis and a problem with measurement in the determination of amount of patrolling for specific areas. The Minneapolis Hot Spot Experiment came about to either validate the findings of the Kansas City Preventative Patrol Experiment or to show its flaws. In early 1995, Lawrence Sherman and David Weisburd chose to conduct an experiment of crime based on Minneapolis addresses. Said experiment had a goal of crime prevention and reduction in “high-crime” areas within the metropolitan Minneapolis region.…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Over the course of the years, there has been various strategies created to make neighborhoods safe all through the United States. During this day and age, our society is extremely risky and it's not simply up to the police to ensure an area is protected, yet the general population of the area needs to volunteer to ensure the area is sheltered too. There are various measures of strategies that as of now have been attempted to alter these continuous issues. Park Heights in Baltimore, Maryland is the area I will concentrate on, which has a high crime rate and needs some crime prevention strategies to help the neighborhood become safe again. Evidence of Disparity…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “Symbolizing crime control," Tim Newburn and Trevor Jones argue that zero tolerance has become a frequent concept in the crime control landscape that has been frequently used by police, politicians and policy makers. The authors suggest that zero tolerance is mostly associated with policing and how zero tolerance is a particular strategy that the police adopted for crime control. Throughout the article, the authors are identifying the key components of zero tolerance and how through the popularity of zero tolerance and how it has been used through its context. In the article, Newburn and Jones begins by addressing the genealogy of zero tolerance.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The National Association of School Psychologists describes zero tolerance policies as school enforced polices that mandate harsh predetermined punishments; typically involving suspension or expulsion. These polices can be implemented for a wide variety of reasons, but were commonly regarded as a solution to school bullying. Critics and scientific researchers often advice against using these polices, which have been shown to have an adverse effect on students of urban backgrounds. Out-of-school suspensions are statistically proven to deter students from receiving a high school diploma; specifically among minority males. Students who do face suspension and expulsion due to zero tolerance policies are at-risk of being caught in the “school-to-prison pipeline”.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the contrary, The War on Cops exposes the truth about officer’s use of force and explodes the concept of “mass incarceration.” A rigorous analysis of data shows that crime, not race, drives police actions and prison rates. The growth of proactive policing in the 1990s, along with lengthened sentences for violent crime, saved thousands of minority lives. In fact, Mac Donald argues, no government agency is more dedicated to the proposition that “black lives matter” than today’s data-driven, accountable police department (Mac Donald, 2016). Mac Donald gives voice so the many residents of high-crime neighborhoods who want proactive policing.…

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The criminal justice system often is examined using political, organizational, or sociological approaches [or lenses] (Pollock, 2010). Asking [simply] whether something is legal [or illegal]…is not necessarily the same question as asking whether something is right [or wrong] (Pollock, 2010). The term “ethics” or “ethical” refers to something “being in accordance with the accepted principles of right and wrong that govern the conduct of a profession.” In the case of police officers, use of discretion, or a lack thereof, in the application of force has direct ethical consequences to which the objectivity of the police officer on scene is subjugated by the subjectivity of a review board after the fact. Actors at every stage in the justice process…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rightful policing The article is an analysis of what has been termed as the racial profiling and arrest of Henry Louis Gates, Jr., as he tried to get into his house by Sergeant James Crowley (Neyroud, & Meares, 2015). The article tries to reconcile the two different point of view held on this one incident one being that the sergeant conducted himself lawfully and the other being that Henry Louis Gates, Jr. was treated unfairly and was a victim of racial profiling. The authors point out that the definition of what racial profiling is typically focuses on how legal the police actions in issue are which legality is a measure of the restrictions placed on when the police decide to initiate contact with people as opposed to how the contact is made (Neyroud, & Meares, 2015).…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The long term impact is felt in black communities where there little to no trust for law enforcement, and that distrust can carry over for generations creating problems for both law enforcement and african americans. The use of police stops whether it be traffic or stop, question, frisk have been seen as a way for law enforcement to target african americans. This policy leads to negative perceptions of police officers “living in neighborhoods where minorities are more likely to be stopped, frisked, and have force used against them may be associated with ill effects for neighborhood residents” (Sewell and Jefferson 2016). Often these tactics are viewed as biased towards blacks and other minorities “the potential role of implicit bias in producing disparity in police interventions was highlighted by a New York City judge in 2013 reflecting on the disproportionate representation of racial/ethnic minorities among people stopped and frisked by members of the New York City Police Department” (Fridell and Lim 2016).…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Zero Tolerance In School

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The implementation of the zero tolerance policy seems to be complicated by school administrators’ fear of violence, resulting in exorbitant suspensions and expulsions of students committing minor infractions against school policy. As these negative incidents involving unjustified suspensions of students increase, the drop-out and failure rates will continue to increase as well. However, the incidence of violence and general disobedience in schools must be addressed. Zero tolerance, if focused specifically on verified violent plans or acts, could be an effective policy for dealing with violent behavior and preventing some violence before it occurs.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The abuse of a police officers privilege to use discretion can result in racial profiling and discrimination, or in other words officers making arrest solely based on the ethnic background of citizens. Although police officers require the ability to exercise discretion in carrying out their tasks, there are concerns that, in some instances this results in discrimination (Griffiths 2013). An officers beliefs or perception of another group of people can cause them to view citizens of a certain ethnic group in negative light, which may influence their use of discretion and decision making. For example, an officer who has a view that certain groups of people are more likely to commit crimes or be violent might use discretion as a tool to unfairly target minority ethnic groups. In 2011, the Montreal police chief admitted that racial profiling was widespread in the police force and the department implemented a number of training initiatives designed to alter the organizational culture and the attitudes and behaviours of officers (Griffiths 2013).…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Modern day America racial profiling has become a major issue. According to Higgins (2008), profiling is a conglomeration of physical, behavioral, and psychological components that increase the probability of apprehending a suspect. During the 1980s, law enforcement began introducing race as a trait for profiling an individual. This was during the rise of drug use in the United States. Racial profiling allowed law enforcement officials to identify drug couriers.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Annotated Bibliography Walker, Samuel. “Police Accountability and the Central Problem in American Criminal Justice.” Holding Police Accountable. Ed. Candace McCoy.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Discretion Essay

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Police Discretion is at the core of policing, allowing officers to approach different situations with different approaches. Discretion is seen as the most essential element of policing, yet discretion is also the source of many problems. Over the year’s discretion has become a more prominent issue amongst the public, and due to social media and the increased use of the internet, videos and new reports can be shared with millions in a matter of seconds. Yet the truth is the discretion an officer’s use is comprehensively subjective to real-world situations rather than adopted by a certain agenda. Police discretion an essential and required part of police work (Schulenberg, 2015, pg.247).…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crime Control Strategies

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When it comes to law enforcement there are two types of strategies used to make police officers more efficient and effective in their line of work. Throughout this paper, we will discuss the two different types of strategies- community relations and crime control strategies. In order to understand the strategies available to police officers, it’s important that we look at all the responsibilities and tasks officers have to face. Most people don’t really think about the type of situations a police officer faces on a daily basis. It can be something as simple as a traffic stop to a high-speed chase or even a shootout.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays