Inaccurate Indian Stories

Great Essays
This picture of the Indians presents one aspect of their culture in which they might recognize themselves. This is a way of shaping identity or reputation, a good way but there is also a bad way. This happens when Indians confess that: “We didn’t begin that way. We haven’t always been entertainment” but due to the lies and deceit and their effects on the Indian people “we ceased being people and somehow became performers in an Aboriginal minstrel show for whites in North America” (King 68). In fact, Indians are to some extent victims of inaccurate stories; these inaccurate stories present another façade of the Indian identity. It is clear that storytelling and even the storyteller had an impact on harmonizing story content but the side effect is the …show more content…
It is so confusing and frustrating for Indians that even among them the feelings toward self-identification is floating between a feeling of invasion by non-Indians and a feeling of being assimilated by non-Indians or becoming an “Apple” the other Indian or half Indian, red on the outside but white inside. These people (“Apples”) are not Indian enough because they carry something from the inaccurate storyteller so King reveals that it is not appropriate for “an “apple” to speak for [a] real Indian” (67). Being Indian enough takes all its meaning from the fact that an Indian should not be a mix of Indian with someone else, but just an Indian. It has to do with the necessity for the Indians to protect their identity, their race and its raw version and be able to auto-identify themselves. Being Indian enough is what it takes to be able to tell true Indian stories/history. Indians have been tricked and abused once, they have been represented and presented in such a wrong way that when the truth about their story is unveiled people express their surprise by saying “you are not the Indian I had in mind” (King,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In chapter one of his book Playing Indian, Philip Deloria discusses the history of Europeans assuming Indian identities for rituals and how this often displaced Native Americans. The concept of displacement of the Native Americans that Deloria explains mirrors the shift that Ira Hayes experiences as a Native American soldier in Clint Eastwood’s film Flags of Our Fathers. Though the time periods are extremely far apart, the sense of Native American displacement as the result of white Americans in the film echoes that in Deloria’s writing. Deloria points out the ways in which Europeans and in turn, colonists, viewed Native Americans in which they separated themselves from the perceived Other of the Native Americans.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native American response paper This response paper will be on the articles A Tour of Indian Peoples and Indian Lands by David E. Wilkins and Winnebagos, Cherokees, Apaches, and Dakotas by Debra Merskin. The first article discusses what the Indian tribes were and where they resided. There are many common terms to refer to the native people including American Indians, Tribal nations, indigenous nations, first peoples, and Native Americans. Alaskan natives are called by their territories like the Inuits or the Aleuts.…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Margaret Laurence’s “The Loons”, and in Emma Lee Warrior’s “Compatriots”, similarly display the many adversities of the Native civilization throughout Canadian history. Struggling to find their place in this world, the Natives are forced to integrate to the dominant culture. Although they battle to find who they truly are, the Natives remained determined to dictate how they should find their identity. In both short stories, the protagonists, Piquette and Lucy face many hardships towards their Native identity. This leads them isolated from their Native culture and their traditions.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sherman Alexie outlines the struggles of several characters in his novel The Toughest Indian in the World. Many of his protagonists suffer from the same quandary related to their Indian heritage, and all of them go to great and unexpected lengths to cure the dissatisfaction they feel with certain aspects of their lives. The narrator Alexie writes about in his short story by the same name, “The Toughest Indian in the World,” encounters an Indian hitchhiker with whom he attempts to combat the destructive beliefs that his father instilled in him as he grew up. The narrator’s only source of cultural identity derives from a father severely lacking in the belief that “the salmon” still exist. Determined to abolish this belief from his own mind, the narrator entrusts the Indian fighter he picks up to show him that there is still hope.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The tribal memoir, Bad Indians by Deborah Miranda is an intricately written body of work that recounts the social and historical story of an entire peoples. The memoir’s use of several different mediums assists in exposing all aspects of Indian life including periods of subjugation through missionization and secularization. The period labeled as “Reinvention” focuses deeply on the wave of immense interest in the study of Indian culture by white men. Miranda includes in this period a section titled “Gonaway Tribe: Field Notes” which recounts the effort of ethnologist, J. P. Harrington to obtain the Indian language through the use of native informants. The use of the term “field notes” implies that the subjects being studied are only samples…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Did you know that fake news was has been a big part of American history Back in the 18th century Benjamin Franklin wrote false false accusations about the indians. “Benjamin Franklin...concocted an entirely fake issue of a real Boston newspaper.” He did this to rile up the the, because we were at war at the time with Britain. Though they really didn’t need it since the war was about finished. But it worked in the war of 1812.…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fitting in is not the easiest thing to do. I went to a predominantly African American middle school in a predominantly African American community. I assumed all schools curriculum were the same but I was wrong. My mom moved us to a community across town that had more Caucasians than African Americans and I had to then transfer schools. At my former school I was a top notch student academically and was sure to carry that reputation with me.…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some people may envision a child being told a story before bed when they hear the term storytelling, but in Native American culture it means so much more. Their stories come in many forms, from complete nonfiction to stories about others in the community to more abstract poems. The stories also almost always have some purpose, whether it be to help a fellow person in grief or entertain an audience. For Native Americans storytelling is incorporated into everyday life, and integrates learning lessons about their past, their beliefs, nature, and just moral lessons. A lot of Native American stories teach wisdom and values, one such story is called “Coyote and Buffalo”, retold by Mourning dove.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This simple statement leads into the interweaving stories of historical accounts King keeps consistent through out his book. Simply put, the stories King has compiled into The Inconvenient Indian were the stories left out in history. The stories that as people who reside on land that does not belong to us, need to hear. King's storytelling calls for a higher truth that at the same time proves inconvenient in the sense that it fights the foundation of what we know as history. Through his storytelling and various accounts of the toxic dumpsites, residential schools, treaty histories, King is able to provide a strong argument.…

    • 1694 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first half of Alexie 's narrative involves his childhood on the reservation. Alexie uses an emotional appeal of his feelings and develops good credibility with a personal anecdote of his family. Throughout the whole paper, Alexie describes mostly emotional. The main stereotypes that Native AMericans are uneducated. Alexie describes, “ A little Indian boy teaches himself to read at an early age and advances quickly……

    • 1087 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With a conflict of trying to overcome racism, a nation has the capability of helping an individual triumph from a deficit. Throughout Indian Horse Richard Wagamese invites us on how Saul manages discrimination. Saul deals with many challenges, however, from help of the Aboriginal community Saul gains success. While surrounding himself with Aboriginals who have faced the same experiences, Saul relies on bonding with people of his own culture to grow as a man. Saul’s forced isolation from the First Nation creates many personal conflicts and impacts his character.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a Sioux Native American, Vine Deloria Jr. has spent a lifetime in the shadow of the stereotypes that falsely represent his culture. In an essay from his book We Talk, You Listen, Deloria Jr. illustrates multiple stereotypes in order to instill a desire within minorities to embrace their heritage and destroy preconceived notions of minority groups, especially Native Americans. Deloria Jr. begins the essay by establishing the types of stereotypes Indians are facing. He alludes to multiple films and television shows to demonstrate the commonplace stereotypes within American society. Indians were portrayed simply as servants to white Americans.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From our interpretation of the fictional short story "One Good Story, That One" by Thomas King, it suggests parody of the religious account of The Garden of Eden (i.e. Adam and Eve). We, as a group, came to the consensus that King seemingly writes from the perspective of a stereotypical Indigenous person who is recounting the story to the best of his ability. Looking at this piece of literature from an educational perspective, it offers an opportunity for students to critically examine the intention behind what is being presented throughout the story. As a group, we decided that this story would be most effective for students to examine in secondary grades. With elementary grade level students, they may have not yet received enough education to have creditable knowledge to draw from when examining this rhetorical piece of literate and, as such, might interpret this differently than King has intended.…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans have always been given the stereotype of "wild savages" by white settlers. The Narrative of the Life of Mrs. Mary Jemison gives a more caring, and human quality to the so-called "wild savages". Through Mary's narrative, the traditions of Native American, as well as the domestic roles of men and women are analyzed. Throughout her captivity, Mary mentions that she was treated with the utmost respect by her Indian family.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hemingway's "Indian Camp" concerns Nick Adams' voyage into the obscure to at last experience and witness the full cycle of conception and demise. In spite of the fact that Nick's experience is a noteworthy topic in the story, social imbalance additionally is an issue that adds to the story's account range. All through this short story, there are numerous cases of racial mastery between Nick's family and the Indians. Dr. Adams' and Uncle George's bigot conduct toward the Native Americans are in light of the historical backdrop of rivalry in the middle of Caucasians and America's indigenous people groups. "Indian Camp" starts at the shore where Nick, his dad, and Uncle George are grabbed by Indians in rowboats.…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays