The Pros And Cons Of The Mental Treatment Act 1945

Improved Essays
The Mental Treatment Act 1945, as amended, forms the legislative basis for the mental health services in Ireland. The MTA 1945 was innovative and enlightened in its day. The former procedure whereby patients were committed to psychiatric hospitals on the order of two magistrates (subsequently Peace Commissioners) was repealed and the Mental Treatment Act 1945 set out the procedures for the admission of both voluntary patients and involuntary patients, other than mentally disordered persons charged with criminal offences and Wards of Court. The Mental Treatment Act 1945 specified two main classes of patients received in psychiatric care -- the voluntary and the non-voluntary patients. There are two categories of non-voluntary patients -- temporary …show more content…
The maximum period of detention of a temporary patient is six months, but if, towards the end of that six month period, the chief medical officer of the institution is of the opinion that the patient has not recovered, he may extend the original period of detention for a further six months up to a total of twenty-four months, or twelve months in the case of an addict. A person of unsound mind is broadly defined in the MTA 1945 as a person who requires detention for protection and care, and who is unlikely to recover within six months. Section 162 deals with a chargeable patient reception order and Section 163, as amended by Section 7 of the Mental Treatment Act 1961, provides for an application for recommendation for reception into a psychiatric hospital. Under Section 163(2) the recommendation must certify that the person is of unsound mind. The medical officer of the psychiatric hospital must examine the person to whom an application for admission as a person of unsound mind refers before he or she signs the reception order. A person of unsound mind may be detained for an indefinite …show more content…
I have already adverted to the right of the patient or someone acting on the patient's behalf to apply to the High Court for an Order of Habeas Corpus both under common law and under the provisions of Article 40.4.2 of the Constitution. This initiates an inquiry as to the lawfulness of the patient's detention and is undoubtedly a speedy and efficacious remedy. However, the situation of a mental patient who is illiterate, harmless and without kith or kin to initiate such an inquiry on his behalf by way of habeas corpus perhaps poses the problem in a stark form. Such a patient may not be aware of his or her rights to seek habeas corpus and may be incapable of the necessary written or verbal communication to trigger such an inquiry. There are other safeguards built into the Mental Treatment Act 1945 (as amended). A patient may apply to the Minister for Health for an Order under Section 222 of the MTA 1945 for the examination of a detained person by two medical practitioners, and the Minister on consideration of their report, if he or she thinks fit, may direct the discharge of the patient. Section 12 of the MTA 1945 provides for the appointment of an Inspector of Mental Hospitals who is a registered medical practitioner and who is normally a psychiatrist. The Inspector must visit all public mental hospitals at least once a year and private hospitals once every six months. He has a duty to give special attention to the state of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays
    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The mentally ill prisoner was isolated his cell for approximately eleven days. When the staff finally checked up on the prisoner, he was found face down, covered in feces, urine and he had a body temperature of 80.6. The mentally ill prisoner was transported to the hospital and died from hypothermia and cardiac arrhythmia(Smith, 2015, para. 36). The end results of this case brings light and awareness of issues of mentally ill patient who are incarcerated for minor charges. They end up in the hands of staff members who are not trained to deals with patients who are mentally ill.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Topic sentence 1: A mentally impaired patient may still able to make decision for his or her healthcare. A mentally-ill patient can still refuse lifesaving treatment even if he or she is known as “mentally ill”. The term itself does not mean that the person is automatically derived from their capacity and rights. It is still very much depend on the patient’s degree of mental impairment. Due to that, all patients must be assessed for their capacity to give consent and must be given opportunity to receive adequate and effective information in helping them to understand the consent regarding such treatment.…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Community Treatment Orders Community Treatment Order (CTO) as a form of mandated outpatient treatment is well established and exists in several jurisdictions in various forms all over the western world. Its concept and practice has generated considerable debate and scrutiny with polarizing views. It presents a case for treatment as a right versus as a choice, and begs the question of whether there can be a balance freedom or coercion for the consumer. In this paper I will provide an overview of CTOs, discuss the issues and weigh in on the existing debate. CTO as a mechanism aims at promoting the consumer good through an inherently coercive process.…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Initially, mental illness was not treated and people were secluded, but as time went by, new laws and policies were administered to advocate for their needs. In earlier years, mental illness was seen as “demonic possessions or religious punishment” () Families and churches were responsible for caring for people with mental illness due to the stigmas of mental illness. But in the 1700s, the first hospital was introduced in Williamsburg, Virginia (). It sounds like a shift towards benefitting people with mental illness, when in fact it was the opposite. They were built to seclude mentally ill people from the rest of the society and they were treated crudely.…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    both penitentiaries and correctional facilities face progressing issues connected with the administration of prisoners with psychological well-being issues and Disabilities. A big issue with regards to the legality of corrections is that most jails are not generally furnished with the assets to manage wrongdoers' with mental issues or meet the needs of those with certain disabilities. The utilization of power is dependably an issue that revisions authorities are worried…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The New Asylums Essay

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After viewing “The New Asylums”, there are many systematic problems, societal shifts, and/or changes in policies that have contributed to “The New Asylums”. One of the main societal shifts that have contributed to the “The New Asylums” is the nation’s shut down of psychiatric centers. This led to the police department to handle the mentally ill that were left on the streets leading to many arrests. However, a prison’s function is not to treat mentally ill patients; their role in society is to provide safety and security to the community. Nonetheless, the prisons do provide many services and treatments to accommodate the mentally ill.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Recommended Changes Todd R. Clear (2004) expressed that “Good intentions do not matter and may in fact, be a detriment.” (Clear, 2004, p. 70) This can certainly be applied to issues in mental health courts that need to be addressed. Nancy Wolff, Nichole Fabrikant and Steven Belenko (2011) findings that mental health courts are shaped by formal and informal selection criteria is extremely problematic, informal selection criteria clearly suggests that an individual may be turned down in one mental health court and accepted in another which is completely unacceptable. Therefore, I recommend the enforcement of well thought-out formal selection criteria to all current and all upcoming mental health courts.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People with mental illnesses face policing with the lack of funding to help people in need. Liat Ben Moshe addresses this problem in her article, “Institution Yet to come.” Moshe discusses the ill treatment of people who have mental illness due to the lack of support they receive from medicine and law. The creation of prisons has created an environment where all public spaces that proved help mentally and physically to be reduced to mental hospitals. Mental hospitals do not have the same label as prisons but that’s what they ultimately are.…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Mental Capacity Act (MCA) is a law which applies to any individual aged 16 and over, who lacks mental capacity. It is a legal framework for all professionals in health care settings. According to the NHS (2015) it was designed to safeguard and empower these individuals to make their own decisions about the care and treatment that they can receive. The MCA was brought into law after the judgement of the Bournewood case, where an individual’s rights were infringed by article 5 of the Human Rights Act, which is the right to liberty and security. The Bournewood case involved an adult male who had profound learning disabilities and was autistic.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Safeguarding Reflection

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The objective of this essay is to reflect on the experience I came across during my clinical placement in one of the NHS trust in London. I will be reflecting on safeguarding vulnerable adult with mental health problem. According to Driscoll (2007) reflection enables health care worker to analyse their practice and seek possible reasoning and different approach to performing their skills. Nursing and Midwifery (2015) states that nurses must maintain confidentiality and privacy.…

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental Illness In Jails

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In that case, with the obstacles the police faces when dealing with mental illness situations, there are two serious issues appears from the current state of criminalization with someone having a mental illness and injury or death as a result of their contact with the police. As noted, officers are in the position to be first responders to serious mental health emergencies; police intervention accounts for a significant amount of referrals into care estimates of 15-40% of the mentally disordered is currently in jails and prisons (Adelman, 2003). Majority of arrest of mentally ill people are for non-serious crimes such as minor theft, noise or disruptions complaints, failure to appear in court following other charges that was either directly or indirectly related to their illness. A study by Rogers, suggest that lack of advance knowledge of mental illness was a contributing factor to arrest (1990). As a result, an arrest was often the only step available for officers in situation where individuals were not sufficiently disturbed too be accepted by hospitals but were too public in their deviance to be ignored.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mental Illness In Prisons

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Today the incoming rate of prisoners has increased immensely, including suicide rates and drug/alcohol addiction. Many of the ways that the patients are diagnosed and treated do not help there case but most are found to worsen the illnesses. This includes one infamous case, the John Salvi case. The way of processing and treating mentally ill in jails has extreme effects on the prisoner and their outside world personas.…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger the main character Holden Caulfield is sent to a mental institution due to the emotional devastation his brother, Allie 's, death had caused him. Cares about his brother so much that he isolated himself from society and his family who put him in the mental institution. Mental institutions continue to advance to help people like Holden Caulfield overcome mental disorders. Mental institutions were created for the reason to help people who have mental disturbances or mental disabilities. “The [Mental] Act [2001] defines mental disorder as mental illness, severe dementia, or significant intellectual disability,” (Citizens Information).…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gaining a patient consent prior to the medical procedure has claimed simple yet imperative process of patient care for nursing professionals as some of the legal implications can occur that may lead to a negligence on clinical care, risk the nursing registration or even criminal assault that is resulting a litigation, if it does not proceed accordingly. Patient’s consent can be obtained in various ways, such as implied, verbal or written forms are available and most importantly, different types of consent will require on the nature of treatment. Informed consent is an ongoing, practical process in relation to the patients’ health care in the clinical setting which would involve providing sufficient information about the clinical procedure and…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays