What Is Viking Barbarity?

Improved Essays
. Instead, demonstrating how “they were no more violent than anybody else, they were no less civilised than anybody else” (Winroth, 2013) of their time.

Professor of archaeology at Stockholm university, Ingmar Jansson, states that “The Norsemen were not just warriors, they were farmers, artists, shipbuilders and innovators”, as well as a host of other vocations. Despite a quarter of the modern Orkney genome appearing to come from Norwegian Vikings, the lack of Danish DNA in modern descendants of Anglo-Saxons despite their long campaign, suggests the original belief of Viking barbarity was not as true as previously thought, because if there was as much rape as claimed, there would have been some trace of it in these modern genetics. The Vikings
…show more content…
William Fitzhugh believes the Vikings were “relatively ruthless, but … this was a ruthless age with far more than just peaceful farmers living peaceful lives”, and Winroth stated in a 2013 interview that, “the Vikings behaved the way early medieval people behaved” and although they were violent, it was “no more than anyone else at the time” (Winroth, 2013). For example, Emperor Charlemagne relied on campaigns for funds to run the Frankish empire, and these campaigns were very bloody, and not even a source as biased as the Royal Frankish annals pretends otherwise. In 774 AD, Charlemagne entered Saxony, “with fires and pillaging devastating everything, and several Saxons who were attempting to resist were killed”. Additionally, during a single day in 782 AD, Charlemagne ordered 4,500 Saxons to be decapitated. In the words of Winroth, “The Vikings execution of 111 prisoners in 845 pales in comparison” and they “never got close to that level of efficiency” However, it is the Vikings who receive the reputation for violence and bloodthirstiness, while Charlemagne in comparison is generally praised as a founding father of Europe. The main reason for this is due to the fact that Charlemagne was a Christian and Holy Roman Emperor, and that the Vikings, unlike Charlemagne, “attacked those with a monopoly on writing, it is their deeds, not Charlemagne’s that have gone down in history as infamous, irrational, and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    One of the fascinating times in European history occurs during the age of the Vikings, which were between the 8th century and the 10th century. There are several different articles that possess different ideas on how the Vikings acted. For example, one article that views the Vikings as harsh and horrific human beings is titled Lindisfarne, which talks about how the Vikings raided a town in current-day England (Lindisfarne). Another example includes a NOVA interview with William Fitzhugh, an archeologist who argues that the idea of the Vikings being “brutal” people is a misrepresentation. The purpose of this interview with Fitzhugh is to make the audience really think about what the Vikings were really like during the end of the Carolingian era going into the Viking era.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Anglo-Saxons are a very prideful tribe that takes honor in everything they do. They basic theory in early history says that the more land you own the more have the more powerful you are. In this novel the Danes portray a Viking role. They believe that it is their sole goal and destiny to imperialize all of England. With each area that they overturn they gain resources, and hostages.…

    • 235 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Chrlemagne Vs Charlemagne

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The strongest of the Franks were the first Carolingians, who had a son named Charlemagne. The powerful Charlemagne and his army conquered land to help his kingdom grow, as well as to help the Pope. Since Charlemagne helped the Pope, the church and the Pope both supported Charlemagne’s decisions as Emperor. Charlemagne wanted a more effective government, so he established a city in Aachen. Since Charlemagne’s empire was so large, he hired counts to help him rule his empire, as well as inspectors to keep an eye on his counts.…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In those wars he so splendidly added to the Frankish kingdom that he nearly doubled its size” (140). In addition to the successful expansion, King Charles “increased the glory of his kingdom by winning over kings and peoples through friendly means”…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Vikings uncommon military tactics along with their strong willed shieldmaidens often intimidated Frankish rulers, many Frankish rulers would even to pay off the Vikings in hopes of preventing farther attacks on their subjects. This did backfire on what is now Paris, in 841CE Frankish King Charles payed a Viking leader 7000 livres of silver and gold for the freedom of Paris, this would be the equivalent of 17,429.30US dollars (without inflation). After hearing tales of how generous the Frankish king was Ragnar Lodbrok attacked the city of Paris in 845 CE with 120 long ships and 5000 Viking warriors lead by in hopes of receiving more than was previously given. Contrary to popular belief, the Viking people did not focus their time on raiding towns or monasteries. They focused their time on trade, forming settlements, and farming their land.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How barbaric were the “barbarians”? If you ask me, the mongol’s were artists that sculpted the society of our modern day world. Not for what they destroyed, though they brought much destruction all over the continent, but for what they built. They came close to uniting Eurasia into a world empire, and in doing so they spread throughout it technologies like paper, gunpowder, paper money, and even the compass. Now look at where we are now.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Viking Weapons

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Pages

    War weapons, to be exact. Viking weapons were just about as brutal and precise as they were, and there were three main types: the spear, sword, and axes. The most common of those three was the spear; they were usually about three meters in length and made with an iron spike for the head. Swords, however, were rare and showed a sign of higher status. The swords of the time were about ninety centimeters blade length and highly customized from their creators/artisans.…

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Víkingr in norse language means pirate or raider, but throughout the world Vikings were also great travelers, traders, and raider. Vikings have been to many places around the world, but they are more than just then travelers and pirates raiding different countries. They were good craftsmen and traders, had various gender roles for women, and good supporting home life with their Norse society. The Vikings society were well known for their craftsmanship as they did various crafts and art forms, for example blacksmith and pots were seen equally acknowledged.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I wanted to choose a topic which would relate to the vikings because I was always very interested in this area of history. I needed to choose a topic more specifically, therefore I chose Vikings trade and exploration because in my opinion it would be a very interesting topic to discuss. To make my research question I needed to narrow it down to specific region of the world. With my instructor's help I came up with '' In what ways did the Vikings influence Europe during the Early Middle Ages in trade and exploration.''…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A classic symbol of Scandinavian female identity, the paired oval or ‘tortoise shell ‘brooches, were sometimes preserved as heirlooms in non-Scandinavian contexts and possibly venerated as emblems of ‘homeland’ identity. Jane Kershaw has studied female displays of Scandinavian association in Scandinavian areas through their choice of dress ornaments. Gender distinctions in expression of ethnic identity are widely observable in modern contexts. These brooches are an acceptable means of distinguishing female from male graves. In 1991 Judith Jesch wrote the first book in English to explore the lives of Scandinavian women from 800-1100, Women in the Viking Age.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Vikings, also known as the Norsemen, the Northman or the Northerners, were warriors, settlers and merchants who came down from Scandinavian to Western Europe for a multitude of reasons. They came to raid, colonise, acquire wealth and power and most importantly to many of them, prove their honour and prowess. The Vikings had a similar in essence, yet slightly different social structure from the English. In the early Viking ages, the Vikings did not have a king, but were each individually ruled over by a separate jarl, who governed the province. A Jarl was similar to a Lord except for the fact that they had more responsibilities than one (e.g. it was much easier for them to lose power, as they had to provide their men with feasts and organise…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Again, one can not ignore the significance of Christianity here and its relations with politics, as Winroth further underlines that 'Unification goes hand in hand with conversion' . It is this unification of different tribes under a sole ruling kingdom that had greatly damaged the Vikings influential reign of terror over Europe, thus bringing the end of the Viking Age in the mid 11th Century. However, the conversion of the Vikings had given way for political manipulation, hence the formation of kingdoms and feudal societies, which were more appropriate and in line with the rest of European culture and society. In addition, we can infer from Winroth, that there appears to be a correlation between the creations of kingdoms and the conversion…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The most important aspect of Viking colonization was the idea that most of their voyages were raids of towns and villages. As stated earlier, these raids started in England in 793, and then expanded as far as Russia, Italy, Georgia, and Spain. A story is shared in an old Icelandic tale, "and we [the Vikings] set fire to the town. And so they did. The Villagers say, ‘You do not want us to go to the Vikings if you will have life and money.’…

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the earlier stages, barbarism was based on agriculture and the rearing of cattle. Civilization was based upon private property, introduced by commodity production. The period of savagery and barbarism constituted the period of “primitive communism”, where there were no restrictions on which men and women could have relations, living in common “long houses” with common property and children would be raised in common. There were many different forms of family and sexual relationship. Some of these were group marriage, monogamy, promiscuous intercourse, to name a few.…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The prospect of Danegeld that is presented by the messenger bolsters the impression that the Vikings are using a cowardly approach to control the Anglo-Saxons, a stark contrast to Byrthnōð’s outspoken attitude. Furthermore, the refusal to reveal themselves to Byrthnōð also suggests that the Vikings are attempting to impose their sense of superiority over the Anglo-Saxons instead of regarding the latter as an equal. This applies an elusive characteristic with the Vikings in comparison to the direct, confrontational nature of the Anglo-Saxons that are perpetrated through Byrthnōð. In this extract, the presence of a messenger instead of a reputable Viking does not frighten Byrthnōð, which is shown when he boldly states that the people would tribute ættrynne ord and ealde swurd (p. 252, l. 47) in response to the commands of the Vikings. The pre-modifying adjectives ‘ættrynne’ and ‘ealde’ reveals the ineffectual properties of the items Byrthnōð presents as a testament to the futile attempt to buy the loyalty of Byrthnōð.…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays