law that he believes should be changed to maintain an epistemic goal of the criminal justice system. He argues that the court system frequently maintains rules that seek to distribute the verdicts so that we have less false convictions than false acquittals whether these rules will aid the system in seeking the truth or not. One of the primary principles currently in place that he believes should be amended is the “Silent Defendant” rule, as he calls it, which allows the defendant the choice of…
Defendant can adduce evidence to show his act was involuntary . If the prosecution fails to do so, the defence succeeds and results in a complete acquittal for any offence charged. Relationship between insanity and automatism distinct by internal and external factor. Significant concern is defendant with diabetes. In R v Hennessy , defendant had no memory that he got into a stolen car and crashed it…
him when left alone in the courtroom. She spills out her entire plan of forging letters to a non existent lover and admitting that she herself was the mysterious woman who handed him the letters which then proved her testimony wrong and led to the acquittal. Furthermore, she admits that the only reason why she saved Leonard was because she loves him. Leonard over hears their conversation and under the law of double jeopardy, he coldly tells her that he has met another woman and abandons her.…
guilty for his acts on multiple occasions. How the interest groups with differing perspectives on abortion were addressed in the documentary was by stating how much support Morgentaler had at the beginning of his charges in comparison to during his acquittals. During the beginning of the series of Morgentaler cases, the majority of society were opposed to abortion and were protesting against Henry Morgentaler. However, as the case progressed more people began to side…
analyzed several other studies involving mock juries that tested both the “strong prosecutor’s effect” and “defendant’s effect,” and additionally gathered court data from multiple states to see if acquittal data has significantly changed over the years since CSI’s pilot. The findings ultimately showed that acquittal rates have not changed drastically over the years in multiple states, but that most jurors that view crime dramas regularly do hold higher expectations for forensic evidence.…
With new technological advancements, it should be thought that this form of evidence is the only reliable source for providing just outcomes in court cases. It is a technique that leads to a criminal’s conviction or acquittal. The many skills and areas of DNA help the reliability of an investigation as each expert area are assigned professionally. Whilst DNA testing can be incorrectly interpreted and used ineffectively leading to false imprisonment, it enhances criminal…
A jury nullification is the point at which the jury knowing and intentionally rejects the proof or refusal to apply the law wither in light of the fact that the jury needs to communicate something specific about some social issue that is bigger than the case itself, or on the grounds that the outcome directed by law is in opposition to the jury feeling of justice, morality, or fairness. In addition, an optional demonstration is not a legitimate sanction capacity of the jury. It is the thought to…
The “CSI Effect” which is the effect of crime television shows on the verdicts made in court cases or on other aspects of the criminal justice system. The perceived rise in acquittals can also plausibly by explained without any reference either to watching CSI or to view crime drama more generally. Tyler (2006), stated, “With an ever-increasing number of crime television programs in which forensic tests are used to solve a case in the course of a single episode. Many criminal justice officials…
Kingsmeat is the title of a short story by Orson Scott Card. While most call it science fiction, I think it's more of a piece with a futuristic-angle than hard science fiction, and is about suffering the consequences of doing what one thinks is right. And Holiness. It's about a race of beings consisting of a king and queen (and all the eggs in her abdomen) who harvest their 'kingsmeat' from the humans of Abbey Colony. After invading the planet, these many-armed and hideous creatures begin…
After reading the support material, I can imagine how the people suffered this day (evening on Monday – March 12, 1770) when eleven guns were discharged. The British soldiers were looking to kill people, but Edward Archbald admonished Mr. Merchant to take care of the sword, one soldier turned round and struck Archbald on the arm, and then pushed at Merchant, cut his and grazed the skin. The noise called more people to fight, John Hicks a young lad, help him and around minute twelve of them…