The way Jay’s story matches certain parts of Adnan’s cellphone’s call log can’t be just a lucky coincidence. He would not be able to pinpoint and describe certain situations and evidence if his story was not true. There’s an outgoing call to a girl named Nisha about an hour after the time slot where Hae supposedly died. The only person who knows Nisha is Adnan, and this places him with the phone. Also relating to the call log, Adnan’s phone pings towers near Leakin park twice at around 7 that night …show more content…
Ask this; if Adnan did not carry out this crime, why is Jay able to tell police specific details about the crime? Jay led the police to Hae’s car (Koenig, “The Deal With Jay”). This shows that he had accurate knowledge of something pertaining to the crime. Also, Jay told police that Hae was buried on her right side, which was how she was found (still searching for where I found this). Again, this shows us exactly how Jay has knowledge of specific things that happened; he would have to be really lucky to guess how she was laying and be correct. He would not have been able to share these things with the cops if he had no knowledge of them,